A big part of the difference between an amateur and a pro is their skill level. Writing consistently good songs requires it. So… what creates skill?
This article by Tony Conniff explores why skill is essential in songwriting, distinguishing professionals from amateurs. While talent and inspiration play a role, consistent success in songwriting comes from learning, practice, and perseverance.
Key Points on Developing Songwriting Skill
1️⃣ Talent: A Starting Point, Not the End Goal
- While some people have natural talent, it is not enough on its own.
- Many great songwriters were not prodigies but developed their skills over time.
- Example: Michael Jordan wasn’t a high school basketball star but worked tirelessly to improve.
2️⃣ Study: Learning from Others
- Studying successful songwriters, musicians, and composers helps improve one’s craft.
- Listening to great songs and analyzing melodies, chord changes, lyrics, and arrangements is crucial.
- Learning can come from books, mentors, teachers, peers, and self-study.
3️⃣ Repetition: Writing, Failing, and Improving
- Writing many songs is necessary to refine technique and develop a unique voice.
- Failed experiments (songs that don’t work out) are valuable learning experiences.
- Great songwriters write a large volume of material before producing standout work.
4️⃣ Desire & Determination: The X-Factor
- Success in songwriting requires sticking with it through setbacks.
- Many successful musicians were not considered the best early on but improved through persistence.
- Songwriters must push beyond the comfort zone to grow artistically.
5️⃣ Skill: The Lasting Asset
- True skill is something no one can take away—it allows a songwriter to create at a high level consistently.
- Beyond skill, there is an intangible quality in great art that can’t be forced or faked.
- Example: The Beatles, Miles Davis, Bob Dylan, Joni Mitchell, and others reached a level beyond technical ability, creating timeless music.
Final Thoughts
Most creatives won’t achieve global fame or artistic immortality, but pursuing mastery is still worthwhile. Writing songs out of passion and personal growth makes the journey meaningful.
